De-Yellowing plastic - the stain isn't permanent after allcleaning plastic de-yellowing peroxide experiment stain
Posted 10 July 2009 - 08:03 PM
Many of you may have suspected it wasn't environmental, but rather "aging". I've had items that yellowed while sealed in plastic inside never-opened factory original boxes, and identical plastics exposed to identical conditions may differ greatly in yellowing: Most of us have seen two-toned chassis where the top and bottom were dramatically different colors after as little as a year. Game consoles, computers and other electronics devices that get warm are particularly prone to this.
It turns out this yellowing is usually the result of bromine released from flame retardants added in the master batch to facilitate production and later molding. (Bromine, you will recall is a dark reddish brown liquid at room temperature) The loss of bromine doesn't necessarily mean that the plastic itself is deteriorated or unable to give decades of further performance, though a mental illusion often convinces us they feel brittle or rough.
It turns out to be relatively easy to remove these stains with common household materials. You may be surprised how "factory new" some items feel after deyellowing. More than once, I've been surprised, because I'd come to believe an item had been beige to start with, but the cleaning (and internal surfaces) reveal that it was originally white or gray.
I'm not going to get too deep into the chemistry (which actually dips into quantum mechanics), but I want to make it clear what we are *not* doing. Though the key chemicals are often used as bleaches and cleaners, the process is not bleaching the plastic or removing dirt. It's just mobilizing the bromine, which has migrated to the surface, and forms a stable complex with atmospheric oxygen. (Note that the bromine didn't stain the full thickness of plastic upon manufacture.)
The second key point is that ultraviolet light is CRITICAL to the process. The UV is what actually mobilizes the bromine -- just as heat and UV often contribute strongly to plastic yellowing, but mobilizing the bromine to the surface in the first place. If you use the solution alone, you may not get appreciable effect from soaking plastics for weeks in you basement. Since you only need a day or so of direct sun (or the equivalent in UV lamp or indirect shaded sun), you won't damage the plastic
Stronger is *not* necessarily better. We're really trying to *limit* the reaction, so ther eaction only reacts with the UV-activated bromine (the easy target) reacts, not the plastic. The plastic is much more resistant, but there's thousands or millions of times as much plastic as bromine present.
Daylight UV isn't a problems --these plastics are designed to stand up to sunlight for much more than a day-- but too-strong UV lamps, too much heat (the rate of the undesired side reactions doubles with every 10C rise in temperature), high peroxide concentrations, too much activator (creating too many free radicals), too long an exposure (after most of the bromine but gone) or letting the cleaner completely dry -- all of these may slightly overclean or even damage the surface. I'd suggest keeping the peroxide under 20% or more: 6% (20 volume) works fairly well (and you don't really need gloves) and even 12% is still pretty mild (and is unlikely to react dangerously with many of the incompatible substances on the MSDS warning). Then, if you see just a wee bit more stain that you want to knock off, try a brief UV session (maybe 30 minutes) at high peroxide concentration.
I originally encountered this idea in a blog entry by someone who restored *deeply* yellowed (actually brown) old game consoles and computers by soaking the cases in big plastic trays full of hydrogen peroxide (and a few other chemicals) on their back porch. I was impressed by the results, but it seemed expensive (and rather a hassle) to fill those big containers with chemicals, especially here in New England, where the weather might not cooperate. Who wants to bring big, heavy, sloshy trays of strong chemicals out of the rain, and store them inside the house?
However, the process seems to work equally well if you mix a smaller batch, add a thickener, and simply brush it on. If one activating chemical is lect out of the mixture, it can be stored for weeks, to be activated and brushed on as needed. The objects can be left out if it starts to rain, and rebrushed when the sun comes out. It's easier than painting.
500 ml (1 pt) Hydrogen Peroxide(H2O2) diluted to 6-12% (20-40 volumes)
While 3% (10-volume) drugstore peroxide can work, it may take many days of UV exposure. Further, since it is borderline to start with, it may not last very long: you may need a new batch each day. Finally, since hydrogen peroxide breaks down to oxygen and water, the stuff in your bathroom (or store) may be substantially less than the stated 3%. ("10 Volume" means that 1 volume of solution will release 10 volumes of oxygen gas. You could easily jury-rig a measurement test, using, say, a dab of manganese dioxide paste from inside a dead dry-cell or alkaline battery as a catalyst)
For quicker, and likely better, results, use a stronger hydrogen peroxide. I'm personally happy with 6-12%, but some go up to the strongest that is easily obtainable e.g. probably Prochem Urine Rescue, available at many custodial or carpet cleaning suppliers (~$20/gal) or pet supply retailers (Petco, Petsmart) for ~$30/gal. It's about 30-32% or "100 volume". Beauty supply shops (like Sally Beauty in the US/Mex/EUR/JAP) sell hair bleaching peroxide up to at least 40 volume (12%) for a few bucks a pint, but you should examine the ingredients. Avoid any with Terpene (which can eat plastic) and generally avoid organic compounds (crudely: anything whose name doesn't trace to ammonia or the periodic table) with one exception: Tetra Acetyl Ethylene Diamine (see below). If it comes premixed in the peroxide (vs. in a separate packet), your deyellowing solution won't last as long in storage.
To dilute peroxide: initial concentration * initial volume = final concentration * final volume
e.g. 30% * 1L = 6% * 5L, so add 4L water to 1L 30% peroxide solution to get 5L 6% peroxide
Though home use peroxides of over 6% should come with warnings enough, I feel obligated to say:
WARNING: Read the MSDS. Hydrogen peroxide is a strong oxidizer and corrosive to skin, eyes, lungs (if inhaled directly), clothing and wood products. It may react violently with some substances, including acids, bases, metals, metal salts, reducing agents, organic compounds, flammable substances. ONLY USE CLEAN GLASS OR PLASTIC CONTAINERS AND UTENSILS AND PROPER SAFETY GEAR (e.g. gloves and goggles). A dab of the black paste found inside a dead flashlight battery, dispersed in some water, will catalyze hydrogen peroxide to oxygen and water for disposal. Add it carefully/sparingly to avoid splatter/boilover of unreacted peroxide.
2.5-5cc (1/2-1 tsp) Oxy-Clean powder (activator)
This contains a small amount of Tetra Acetyl Ethylene Diamine (TAED) which acts as a catalyst for the hydrogen peroxide in our deyellowing solution. Oxy-clean also has perborates and perchlorates (which is what the TAED is *meant* to catalize) These may add a little something to the deyellowing process, but I never bothered to compare it with pure TAED.
Food Thickener (optional, only use for paste form)
I suggest food thickeners beause they are cheap, available, and shouldn't contain any incompatible contaminants that react with peroxide. I suggest making a roux, slurry or cooking the thickener to paste, as you would with food, before adding peroxide. NEVER heat anything containing hydrogen peroxide on your stove. Make a thick goo, cool, then mix it with the peroxide. I use a magnetic stirrer to avoid putting metal in contact with peroxide, but many report using hand or kitchen blenders to mix the peroxide paste, over months of experiments, so I guess steel, especially stainless, must be okay. I definitely wouldn't even think about an aluminum blade or pan.
Arrowroot, flour, cornstarch, potato starch, xanthan gum, CMC/carboxymethylcellulose, guar gum or food thickeners sold to help older people swallow all work, and are available in grocery or health food stores. I use Xanthan gum, because I bought a big bag for food experiments, but found it a bit slimy for my tastes. A few mil of glycerine really helps Xanthan thicken up.
You can dilute the peroxide and mix with thickener weeks in advance. Always store peroxide and its mixtures in a cool dark place in a glass or plastic container, but not on a wood shelf or on paper liner. It may slowly decompose to water and oxygen, especially if the container isn't scrupulously clean. Don't cap it so tightly that it will burst from internal pressure if you forget it.
Set up a place to "sun" the plastic object all day. You can hang it from strongs over a plastic tray to expose all sides, or just lay it down yellow side up. If possible, arrange a loose transparent cover to prevent drying. Make sure pets, children, stupid friends, etc., can't get at it. The reaction will work, but more slowly, in a shaded location with good exposure to clear sky, or on a lightly cloudy day. You may prefer shade in hot climates in summer: the modest heat of the reaction added to the heat of direct summer sun could dry the paste or warp some plastic parts
You can set it up indoors with a UV lamp, but place the lamp at least 18" (50cm) from the tray, so the heat from the lamp doesn't add to the heat from the reaction.
Resist the temptation to deyellow intact electronics. I know some of you will do it anyway, once you've had some practice, but don't say I didn't warn you. (Trained mockers are standing by!) Instead, remove the chassis as much as possible, put sandwich bags over any remaining exposed metal, Remove any logos, stickers or decals (especially aluminum sheet decals or aluminum shielding paint inside some electronic devices, both of which can get quite eaten up and cause splotchiness) -- a heat gun or hair dryer will help you peel them off intact with a sharp razor blade. If you prefer, seal them in situwith wax, hot glue, or even tape (but tape isn't always reliable for this)
Just before use, dissolve the small amount of Oxy-clean in some water then mix that into your goo. Brush it liberally into the yellowed surfaces. You may choose to wrap the piece in clear plastic kitchen wrap to reduce evaporation: drying concentrates the ingredients and can cause splotchiness.
If you've done everything properly, the brushed-on paste should quickly foam a bit under the UV.
I'd try to check in on the progress every few hours, until you get a feel for the strength of you personal recipe. In my experience, a 6-12% peroxide mix should nearly or completely deyellow a chassis in 3-8 hours with no damage if the piece is left from dawn to dusk.
A TRIAL OF TOTAL IMPROVISATION
After a few tries, it becomes very easy. In fact, the reason I wrote this up was because I did a totally slap-dash job this morning that came out fine. I needed to de-yellow the diffuser (cover) of a large fluorescent lamp for a project, but we've only had maybe half a dozen fully sunny days in he last two months. As I was headed out the door, I remembered this would be one of those days, but I didn't have time to mix a batch, find a big enough tray, etc., so this is what I did:
Reasoning that the translucent diffuser would be fairly transparent to UV, and was also not nearly as badly yellowed as an opaque object of similar ugliness, I sprinkled a pinch of oxyclean in a large sheet of plastic wrap, placed the diffuser on top, then sprinkled another pinch of oxyclean. I then folded the saran wrap around the diffuser, put it in a shallow cardboard tray to keep the ends from unfolding, and carried it to the sunniest part of my deck, where I carefully opened one end, and poured in some ordinary 3% peroxide (probably much weaker -- it was old).
In spite of taking so many liberties, each of which weakened the deyellowing effect, the job was mostly done when I got home. Had I not been using old 3%, I would have rinsed it off, to avoid undesired non-UV peroxide reactions that might slowly make the plastic brittle, but since the "3%" was probably more like1-2% to start with, and is probably much less now, I just left it out for tomorrow, to do what it can with the morning sun, if I stagger home in the wee hours tonight.
Posted 10 July 2009 - 10:51 PM
Posted 11 July 2009 - 12:13 AM
It'd depend on the item and the plastic, of course, but 80F is pretty safe. Heck, I did it at over 80F today and didn't think twice, but your direct sun is stronger than mine.
How about below 90F (32C)? Injection molded plastic parts can warp enough to affect their fit (due to internal molding stresses) at as little as 125F-135F, even though an intact chassis may not be affected at that temperature (When assembled, it is uniformly loaded/reinforced by design). Take 90F air temperature plus heat from direct sun (the inside of a car can exceed 140+ on a 90F day), the cleaning reaction, the breakdown of hydrogen peroxide -- you get the idea
Most of the bromine in the plastic is still there, and will continue to mobilize. so yellowing may recur in time, especially if the plastic is exposed to heat and UV. I don't have a way to stop that BUT since the problem isn't really bromine or its mobility, but the fact that it reacts with atmospheric oxygen to stabilize at the surface as a brown stain, you might try rubbing the cleaned, dried parts with Armor-all or similar to reduce contact with oxygen.
Furniture polish may work. I diligently hand-rubbed my weight machine with furniture polish when I got it in the early 90s, and it doesn't have any rust, but I've seen similar untreated machines rust in just a few years, even unused.
Ironically, bromine and bromide solutions tend to be fairly decent oxidizers and bleaches, themselves. But as I said this reaction isn't as much about bleaching or oxidizing or cleaning, it is about destabilizing the surface bromine.
Posted 11 July 2009 - 04:26 PM
Thanksgiving to Christmas time might work. Temps are usually under 90 by then.
Posted 12 July 2009 - 02:52 AM
Gosh, for a minute there I thought you were channeling the late Billy Mays.
Posted 12 July 2009 - 07:30 PM
I have a vintage thing that is molded in white. Made in the 80's, and has yellowing on the plastic. How far through, I don't know. Looks good on one side, yellowing on the other. Some areas are painted and I do NOT want to remove the paint as I will never be able to match how it was done from the factory. Will your formula damage the paint?
Also, can I just use oxy clean? Or do I have to mix it with Hydrogen Peroxide? If so, do I really need food thickener or can I get by without it? Thanks.
689 Reasons to Defeat Barack Obama in 2012:
Posted 12 July 2009 - 09:02 PM
The results with 70s/80s ABS have been quite good. There is only occasional surface damage, almost always from use of >12% (>40 volume) peroxide, overly long exposures (days) and/or preexisting UV damage from many years in a window or in a fluorescent-lit office. The damage I've seen pictures of has been very mild -- a superficial roughening from removal of a thin layer of damaged plastic or a light mottled "flush" which can be mostly evened out with Armorall.
Many of these consoles had painted logos, adhesive decals, pop-out plastic logos (e.g. the Apple logo on early Macs was a pop-out piece which could be pushed out from its apple shaped depression through a hole on the inside of the case) or aluminum logo plates. These should be removed, if possible (a hot air gun and a sharp razor work well) or thoroughly sealed to keep the peroxide out: there is a definite risk of damage to decals/paint and aluminum may react/dissolve.
Try Googling "peroxide" and your item. Someone may have already tried it.
You definitely need the peroxide and UV. While the perborates and perchlorates of the Oxy-Clean may help, we're really using it for its trace of of TAED catalyst, which acts on the hydrogen peroxide. Almost any other catalyst will break hydrogen peroxide down to water and oxygen or active oxygen radical (which is also how it spontaneously breaks down by itself), but TAED apparently catalyzes a different pathway in addition to the usual one, releasing trace H+ ions, which are normally added to chemical reactions via acid. As I said, the small amount of catalyst keeps it all under control.
You don't need a thickener. I first saw it in the blog of someone who used immersion trays. Thickener is just a convenient/economical way to keep the peroxide mix in contact with the plastic during hours of UV illumination.
If the entire chassis is painted vs just logos, it may not be a suitable material for this process.
Posted 14 July 2009 - 10:09 PM
Works for me.
Never tried it on other plastics, never had a reason to.
Posted 15 July 2009 - 10:23 AM
For non-Canadians: methyl hydrate (= MeOH = CH4OH) is just another name for methanol. Its the preferred name for gas line anti-freeze on "Ice Road Truckers" (a History Channel series on the Canadian ice roads)
Posted 06 August 2012 - 04:27 PM
edited to add: There are three guest currently viewing this fascinating thread. I find that very intriguing.
Edited by Mark, 06 August 2012 - 04:28 PM.
Discussion is an exchange of knowledge: argument is an exchange of ignorance.
Peace is not the absence of conflict, but the ability to cope with it.
APOGEE MESSAGE BOARD
Posted 07 August 2012 - 01:07 AM
So reduced to its basics, you only need drugstore peroxide and a touch of activator -- both of which you probably already have.
As with so many things, the more you do it, the less precise you find you need to be, until after a dozen or so tries, you can get by with a lick and a promise. Carl Jung called this "morphic resonance" and used it to explain why some scientific hallmarks (like the crystallization of new substances) may be all but impossible for years, but once achieved, soon turns out to be easily done by any undergrad in any obscure college closet. His theory may be a bit metaphysical for most people's tastes, but it's such a strong empirical experience (once you think to look) that perhaps a little metaphysics can be forgiven or even desired.
-- Orpheus "never underestimate the power of a lick and a promise"
Posted 07 August 2012 - 03:00 AM
Mark: Like so many of my past relationships.
Discussion is an exchange of knowledge: argument is an exchange of ignorance.
Peace is not the absence of conflict, but the ability to cope with it.
APOGEE MESSAGE BOARD
Posted 27 January 2015 - 03:05 PM
I used a variation of this technique and it worked for me.
The Lazy Woman's Variation:
I used a small amount of OxyClean detergent in a small drinking glass, approximately 1 teaspoon but I didn't measure. I added hydrogen peroxide 3% from the grocery store. I stirred it with my finger, added the plastic piece I wanted to de-yellow, and then filled the glass up with hydrogen peroxide until the plastic piece was covered. I placed this in a southern exposure window (it is winter, so it only gets a few hours of sunlight daily if I am lucky). I changed the solution every two days, which is about how often I thought about it. When I changed the solution, I rinsed out the glass and started over with fresh solution.
It took about a week, and the plastic is completely white now. I don't have to buy a new bike light. Thanks for the great tip!
Edited by happy, 27 January 2015 - 03:14 PM.
Posted 27 January 2015 - 09:08 PM
Now I'll make a special effort to try it on other things. E,g. I've had entire loads of whites ruined by a single brand-new pair of red panties (not mine -- but some guests have taken the label on my "underwear" laundry bin the wrong way). I'm sure we've all had some similar dye-transfer experience. If catalyzed peroxide works on that, it'd be a breakthrough in laundry science.
Posted 17 March 2015 - 10:54 PM
Posted 19 March 2015 - 10:47 PM
It's so simple, that there is no reason to try. really, if the tub is plastic: 2qts of drug store hydrogen peroxide would be plenty for even a very large tub. A tablespoon or three of Oxy-clean borrowed from a neighbor would be more than enough activator for two quarts (it is the nature of catalysts to require very little to work, given enough time, because they are not consumed in the reaction) and almost any thickener would work (I suggest creating slurry of corn starch and water, thickening it on the stove, adding water until you have 2-4 quarts about the consistency of a thin pudding, then allowing it to cool completely before mixing in the activator and peroxide.
All told, that's just a few dollars in ingredients, without much chance of damage to your tub. I personally like to spread it over large areas [like a whole tub] with a paintbrush then laying "saran wrap" (or any generic equivalent) over the goo, lightly squeezing most trapped air so it can get several day's worth of UV/sunlight without drying to a powder.
But TBH, you probably won't bother (because it sounds like much more trouble than it actually is) unless you try de-yellowing some smaller plastic item first. It really works like magic -- just a little more work than the lying "magic" that they show on TV ads for commercial cleaning products.
This is completely typical. Take, for example, those headlight lens-cleaning products. They work fine, if you put enough time and elbow grease into them -- but they are optimized to show "a bit more benefit in a bit less time" than better-result processes with household cleaners (If there is any secret at all, I would say it's this: use a UV-protectant sealer, so the results last for years. Without that, the UV damage can recur it a single sunny summer, because any functional de-yellowing/de-fogging scrapes off the UV protectant built into the headlamp lens cover at the factory.)
Posted 04 April 2015 - 08:11 PM
This information is fantastic -- thanks! Am I too hopeful to think that it may work on my 1999 Dodge Dakota headlight lenses? They are somewhat amber now... even though the truck has less than 100k on it...
Regardless, I will be able to restore a cool Coleman "refrigerator" cooler from the 70's that I just picked up, thanks to this info. The trays have yellowed, but it seems as though your solution may work well in this case!
Posted 04 April 2015 - 10:46 PM
Keep on trying things, and please report back your victories.
I often feel inordinately proud of successful projects that seem too minor to tell others. I've decided that it's not the cleverness of the 'hack' but the degree to which it embodies "the maker spirit"
1999 Dodge Dakota headlights don't use much (if any) bromine based plasticizers, so you're really looking at abrasives to remove oxidation. Some people even do the whole job with toothpaste or other mild abrasives, but I'd start with 600-grit sandpaper. You could start with 400-grit if the yellowing is unusually heavy, but 600 is a good compromise between quick removal of oxidized plastic and ease of later polishing.
You can use a power tool, like an abrasive pad, steel wool holder, or rubber/foam sanding pad on a drill (That's how I'd probably start because I'm a Tim-the-Toolman Taylor style caveman -- but I'm heading away from hat as I grow older/wiser) but it doesn't take much longer to do it by hand with a rubber/foam sanding block or (especially) sandpaper stapled around a piece of scrap wood. sandpaper stapled to wood scrap (stapled on the "sides" not on the sanding face) is "grandpa's solution" [my grandpa -- and I'm technically old enough to be a grandpa myself] is actually quite fast and gives better control if you pay attention to the curves you are sanding. Manual sanding with a block Is enjoyably Zen, not boring, when you consider that power tools don't take much less time: a wood block cuts away oxidation more firmly but carefully, and can safely cut faster than a blind power tool)
Whatever you choose initially (you can start with a quick pass with 100-grit, but I consider that too greedy/hasty), you'll have to work in stages, and the headlight cover will look horribly fogged after the first (bulk removal) stage. After 600, you can move to 1000-1500 grit, and then to 1500-2000, then a polishing compound (some people use toothpaste on a drillpad). It sounds tedious, but it only takes a couple of hours, tops, for the entire process. Just remember: do more of your work in the higher grits (which remove imperfections left by lower grits). Low grits remove the brittle oxidized plastic much more quickly, but won't give you the final result you want. 400 (optional) -> 600 -> 1500 -> 4000 -> polish is one reasonable sequence of grits.
If you're ever in doubt, just move to a higher grit when the headlight cover is completely uniform at the grit-level you're working at
When the pros do it, the lens looks near-perfect before they seal it, but you don't have to be so perfectionistic. If you're pretty happy with the uniformity of your results at 2000-4000 grit, you'll be thrilled with the results after you apply the sealant. It will turn totally clear.
Don't take my choice of grit numbers to seriously: it's partly based on doing body work as a teenager (when we all drove jalopies), but they were equally determined by the mix of sizes in the cheap "fine" assortment at the store I was at, the last time I bought bulk sandpaper.
(BTW, I don't usually recommend Harbor Freight or other bottom-rate sandpapers because they shed their grit too fast. Headlight cover plastic is so soft they would probably still work fine. I just prefer to stock *only* good quality sandpaper because you never know what your next project will be)
Posted 04 April 2015 - 11:27 PM
Thanks very much -- and I will follow your advice on the Dakota. I also agree about Harbor Freight. They have some items which can't be beat at their low cost, but fasteners and sandpaper are not among them...
Your knowledge (and willingness to share it) is very valued. The internet was not a "thing" until I was already 35, so it still amazes me that people are so generous with their experience and wisdom. It is a gift that I very much appreciate.
Money is not plentiful at this particular time, so I have re-discovered my "maker's spirit". It is extremely satisfying to make things out of other things -- very creative, too. The last time I saw this kind of DIY attitude was in the 70's. Looks like something great came out of that decade after all....
All the Best,
Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: cleaning, plastic, de-yellowing, peroxide, experiment, stain
Orbis Terrarum →
4 user(s) are browsing this forum
0 members, 4 guests, 0 anonymous users